The adventures of Mommy woman
Is it racial?
Published on November 12, 2003 By JillUser In Current Events
Did any of you wonder why Jessica got so much attention? Did you hear mutterings about the African-American woman (Shoshana) that got shot in both legs? I did.

I watched the Jessica Lynch interview last night. There was a lot of information to be gleened out of the sensationalism. I finally think I understand what the deal is. Basically, there were no witnesses to what exactly happened to Jessica. Everyone else in her vehicle died. She herself isn't even a very good witness since she was unconcious a lot. The government and media decided to fill in the blanks on their own.

They said she went down fighting to the death. They said she shot several Iraqis. When she came back, she told them that was untrue. In fact, she huddled, prayed and didn't fire a single shot (she says her weapon jammed). They decided it wouldn't serve anyone to retract their previous stories.

Shoshana on the other hand, was with a group that were held by the Iraqis. Noone could take artistic license with what happened to her because there were witnesses and footage. I personally think, and know others will disagree, that if you had switched Shoshana with Jessica, there would be no difference. Shoshana would be the girl on Primetime with Diane Sawyer and Jessica would be at home, depressed.

There is also question about how the military is treating the ladies differently. From what I gather, the military determines disability pay according to injury (which makes sense to me). Jessica is recieving much more disability pay than Shoshana and here is why: Jessica's spine is so damaged that her bladder and bowels are paralyzed. The doctors have been trying electric stimulation but she has not been responding. It is most likely a permanent disability. Her left leg was completely shattered from the knee down and her foot on that leg was crushed. She has metal plates and pins from practically head to toe. Shoshana has two damaged legs and depression as a result of torture.

In conclusion: I originally thought racism. I looked at the facts and now believe otherwise. No matter how you slice it, I feel terribly about what both ladies endured and am grateful for their service and the service of all who served and are serving.
Comments (Page 3)
3 Pages1 2 3 
on Dec 10, 2003
B.S.
on Dec 11, 2003
I am not sure what the BS refers to but I agree if it refers to the "100%" disability. Who pays for the disability pay? If some magical entity would pay disability then I would say all of our VFWs should get it. I grew up knowing friends of my Grandfather's with missing limbs and trauma both physical and mental that you wouldn't believe. None of them have been on a talk show or have a book. And none of them got big old disability payment either.

Try getting any job that will give you 100% disability. Do police officers or firefighters?
on Dec 13, 2003
I think the fundamental question for both Jessica and Shoshana is: Assuming the process fair - which I am willing to do - is the pension sufficient on it's face ?

Is this enough for what they are going to continue to be hamperred with throughout their lives ?

I do not think so.
on Dec 13, 2003
I served in the military duing Desert Storm, as a Black Hawk crew member. Testing the GPS
systems for the ground troops. I enjoyed my time in the military(6 years), so I dont think you quite understand the situation as I see it.
Both women were injured during war defending this country, both women should be compensated(equally)! Both women were injured, emotionally, mentally, as well as physically. Both women should be compansated (equally), also did you notice, Shoshana does not have a book deal, movie deal, or offers to be put through college, she is not invited on late night t.v. talk shows. I suppose Shoshana might actually need the disability check, unlike Jessica who is now well on her way to becoming well off, as well as aquiring celebrity status.
I believe that both women, if not treated equally by the media should be treated equally by the country they were defending. Dont get me wrong I am sickened by the spin our military
put on Jessica's story, while ignoring the other prisoners men and women alike. They are showing their true colors even more with this disability issue. This time even you should see this has nothing to do with "playing the race card", fair is fair.
on Jan 06, 2004
JESSICA LYNCH IS NO HEROE!!! SHE GOT CAUGHT. IF YOU WANT THE DEFINITION OF A HEROE TALK TO A VIETNAM VET. SHE IS ONLY GETTING ATTENTION CAUSE SHE IS A FEMALE. WHERE ARE THE ARTICLES ABOUT ALL THE OTHER POWS. THERE ARE SO MANY CONFLICTING STORIES WHO KNOWS WHAT HAPPENED. WE ARE THANKFUL FOR HER SERVING IN THE ARMED FORCES BUT WHERES THE PUBLICITY FOR THOSE WHO DID THEIR JOBS AND DID NOT GET CAUGHT.
on Jan 08, 2004
Arguing that both should be compsenated equally is absurd. Jessica Lynch's injuries were vastly more serious than Shoshana's. And Jessica will be living with those injuries on a daily basis for the rest of her life.

Jessica isn't a hero, but then again, she never said she was. She got a lot of publicity because she was rescued prior to the end of hostilities. Shoshana was turned over at the end of hostilities (formal hostilities anyway). The fact Shoshana got mention at all is amazing given that her situation was identical to several other soldiers who were captured with her.

Lynch's rescue is what made her famous, not because she was white or female.
on Jan 25, 2004
to present fairness and balance please exclude the extent of Shoshsana Johnson's torture
on Feb 11, 2004
She was tortured no more and no less than th eother service men captured with her. Who, I might add, don't get any attention at all.
3 Pages1 2 3